F&M Basketball All-Americans
| Donnie Marsh |
1977, 1979 |
| Dennis Westley |
1981 |
| Terry Scott |
1987, 1988 |
| Phil Hoeker |
1989 |
| Brad Markey |
1989 |
| Chris Finch |
1991, 1992 |
| Will Lasky |
1991, 1992 |
| Charlie Detz |
1994, 1995 |
| Dave Jannetta |
1994, 1995 |
| Mike Mehaffey |
1996 |
| Jeremiah Henry |
1996 |
| Alex Kraft |
2000, 2001 |
| Steve Juskin |
2004 |
| Duran Searles |
2004 |
| James McNally |
2010 |
| Georgio Milligan |
2011, 2012 |
CoSIDA Academic All-Americans
| Jerome Maiatico |
1997-1998 |
3rd Team |
| Jerome Maiatico |
1998-1999 |
2nd Team |
| Jerome Maiatico |
1999-2000 |
1st Team |
NCAA Postgraduate Scholarship Recipients
Conference Players of the Year
| Donnie Marsh |
1976 |
Donnie Marsh
|
1977 |
| Donnie Marsh |
1979 |
Terry Scott
|
1987 |
| Brad Markey |
1989 |
Will Lasky
|
1991
|
Chris Finch
|
1992 |
| Dave Jannetta |
1994 |
| Dave Jannetta |
1995 |
| Jeremiah Henry |
1996 |
Alex Kraft
|
2000 |
| Alex Kraft |
2001 |
James McNally
|
2010 |
| Georgio Milligan |
2011, 2012 |
National Player of the Year
| Georgio Milligan |
2012 - DIII News |
