Al Brooks Defensive Player of the Year

2004 – Chris Stepien
2005 – Chris Stepien
2006 – Tim Barry
2007 – George Farrell
2008 – James Gregory and Zach Romash
2009 – Barry Lovett and Jeff Kellar
2010 – C.T. Marsh
2011 – Kenny Provost
2012 – Sam Massaro
2013 – Brendan Wengerter
2014 – Brian Velasco and Ryan Young
2015 – Jon Cox
2016 – Steve Elf
2017 – Joe Granahan

2018 - Joe Granahan