Year: Captain(s)
|
| 1977: None selected |
| 1978: Flere Powell, Kathy Hamilton, Kim Perry |
| 1979: Anne Ricciuti, Sue Bowen |
| 1980: Sue Bowen |
| 1981: Janet Stevens |
| 1982: Debbie Morrison, Melinda Reuter |
| 1983: Eve Dintino, Kim Idler, Leanne McFalls |
| 1984: Emily Goldstein, Maureen Mahoney, Donna Zaccaria |
| 1985: Faith McCracken, Randi Thomas |
| 1986: Angie Barry, Beth Shillingford |
| 1987: Julie Bahr |
| 1988: Elizabeth Eide, Maria Gaydos |
| 1989: Kelly Bagby, Tina Stathis |
| 1990: Annemarie Merow, Suzy Smith, Beth Weiner |
| 1991: Annemarie Merow, Beth Weiner |
| 1992: Nancy Benzel, Jane Rinehimer, Paige Worth |
| 1993: Katie Aman, Michele Ferris, Lauren Petrella |
| 1994: Melissa Kohler, Lauren Petrella, Suzy Mauk |
| 1995: Jamie Lipari, Suzy Mauk, Anju Rao |
| 1996: Cindy DeFelice, Tami Videon |
| 1997: Kara Silberg, Dana Wright |
| 1998: Lee Richardson, Amanda Roach, Kara Silberg |
| 1999: Audra Krupp, Sarah Reigner, Kasey Ryan |
| 2000: Megan Bermingham, Elsa Ermer, Kim Kelly, Frances Puleo |
| 2001: Megan Bermingham, Genevieve Moyer |
| 2002: Laura Langmore, Madhavi Rao, Kellianne Woods |
| 2003: Laura Fine, Lauren Paul, Emily Shaner |
| 2004: Alexis O'Meara, Allison O'Meara, Julie Rice |
| 2005: Alexis O'Meara, Allison O'Meara, Julie Rice |
| 2006: Eileen Keever, Holly Rutherford |
| 2007: Kelly Cassels, Sloan Giampa, Emily Gill |
| 2008: None selected |
| 2009: Ashley Bevington, Amanda Miceli, Sarah Meisenberg, Lidia Sanza |
| 2010: Paulette Cutruzzula, Blake Hargest, Amanda Miceli, Lidia Sanza |
| 2011: Katie Delaney, Cat Serpe |
| 2012: N/A |
| 2013: Jen Noon, Lauren Selawski, Maggie Mae Shields |
| 2014: Christie Bonfiglio, Ali Kelly, Mary Mitchell |
| 2015: Emily D'Erasmo, Megan Kelly, Brittney Jorgenson |
| 2016: Samantha Blicht, Caroline Doran, Anastasia Mergner, Grace Saliba |
| 2017: Sarah Bozzo, Vanessa Budd, Gabby Frank |
| 2018: Paige Moriarty, Aly Saliba, Hannah Serling |
| 2019: Maddie Hughes, Carolina Kolva, Bridget O'Donnell |
| 2020: Maggie Hanzsche, Clare Monaghan, Katharine Yenke |
| 2021: Emily Kitchin, Ally Marino, Marissa McGarrey, Erin Phillips |
| 2022: Emily Kitchin, Ally Marino, Marissa McGarrey, Erin Phillips |
| 2023: Maddy Birch, Sydney Lowe, Mary Pat McKenna, Ava Turner |
| 2024: Madison Bray, Gillian Brennan, Delaney Liston |
| 2025: Megan Bizub, Lydia Cassilly, Ellen Kelly, Lane Lambeth |
