Year: Captain(s)
|
| 1923-24: None elected in first season |
| 1924-25: Owen Horner |
| 1925-26: Owen Horner |
| 1926-27: Owen Horner |
| 1927-28: Wilbur Lehman |
| 1928-29: George Reimer |
| 1929-30: Ernest Horner, Joseph Shutt |
| 1930-31: Paul Hollinger |
| 1931-32: Paul Hollinger |
| 1932-33: Paul Cassel |
| 1933-34: W. Roy Phillips |
| 1934-35: Russell Bleakley |
| 1935-36: Franklin Horner |
| 1936-37: George Hetrick, Henry Raab |
| 1937-38: Adam Fisher, David Burk Nagle |
| 1938-39: Appointed for each meet |
| 1939-40: Appointed for each meet |
| 1940-41: Frank Burgess, Ross Hamsher |
| 1941-42: Albert Schacheman |
| 1942-43: No team |
| 1943-44: None elected |
| 1944-45: No team |
| 1945-46: No team |
| 1946-47: Joseph Golego |
| 1947-48: Jared Farrier |
| 1948-49: Stanley Mousetis |
| 1949-50: Stanley Mousetis |
| 1950-51: Charlie Cope |
| 1951-52: Ed Barnes, Russell Schelling |
| 1952-53: Carl Bemiller |
| 1953-54: Stan DuBelle |
| 1954-55: Hal DeHaven |
| 1955-56: Rudolph Meyers, Gerry Yoder |
| 1956-57: Ron Flemming, Dave Horner |
| 1957-58: Charles Pfrommer, Joseph Yeats |
| 1958-59: Cleon Cassel, Charles Pfrommer |
| 1959-60: Cleon Cassel, Horace Taylor |
| 1960-61: Clifton McClain, Conrad Zimmerman |
| 1961-62: Donald Horn, Melvin Mounts |
| 1962-63: Melvin Mounts, Conrad Zimmerman |
| 1963-64: Dale Kistler |
| 1964-65: Paul Martin, Mike Wood |
| 1965-66: Bill Schneiderman, Saul Shimansky |
| 1966-67: James Clair, David Crikelair |
| 1967-68: Bruce Leonard, James Clair |
| 1968-69: David Crikelair, John Homiak |
| 1969-70: John Hilliard, Aaron Malinsky |
| 1970-71: Terry Bowen, Andy Noel |
| 1971-72: Andy Noel |
| 1972-73: Appointed for each meet |
| 1973-74: Appointed for each meet |
| 1974-75: Bill Kametz, Brett Senior |
| 1975-76: Clarke Griffin, Steve Paterno |
| 1976-77: Steve Paterno, Brad Warner |
| 1977-78: Bill Myers |
| 1978-79: Brian "Nip" Brown, David Hernley |
| 1979-80: Brian "Nip" Brown, John Mousetis |
| 1980-81: Craig Blackman, Eric Wenzel |
| 1981-82: Gary Beyer, Patric Wallace |
| 1982-83: |
| 1983-84: Marc DeGennaro, Dave Gable, Paul Marshall |
| 1984-85: |
| 1985-86: Craig Cassel, Dave Gable, Andy Katz |
| 1986-87: Andy Katz, Tim Yoder |
| 1987-88: John Johnston, Jace McKeighan, Mark Micolucci |
| 1988-89: John Johnston, Jace McKeighan, Jay Weiss |
| 1989-90: Brian Fisher, Jay Weiss |
| 1990-91: Stephen DeRafelo, Keith Gibel, James Nalbone, Robert Nusum |
| 1991-92: Brian Cuddy, Stephen DeRafelo, Matthew Shearer |
| 1992-93: Victor Bernardino, Brian Cuddy, Jeffrey Root, Matthew Shearer |
| 1993-94: Mike Martin, Ed Moore, Andy Schrader |
| 1994-95: Scott Auker, Jon Koteski, Bryon Magill |
| 1995-96: Bryan Icenhower, Jon Koteski |
| 1996-97: Joel Groft, Jordan Keller, Greg Knox, Glenn Reiss |
| 1997-98: Brendan James, Greg Knox, Glenn Reis |
| 1998-99: Carlos Cuevas, Brian Kapp |
| 1999-00: Carlos Cuevas |
| 2000-01: Bobby Crick |
| 2001-02: |
| 2002-03: Isaiah Hankel |
| 2003-04: Rich Gebauer |
| 2004-05: Rich Gebauer |
| 2005-06: RP Norley, Joe Peretta |
| 2006-07: Justin Herbert |
| 2007-08: Al Gianforti, Justin Herbert, Nico Somers |
| 2008-09: Jake Bucha, Al Gianforti, Justin Herbert, Nico Somers |
| 2009-10: Jake Bucha, Matthew Gittleman |
| 2010-11: Anthony Bongarzone, Jake Bucha, Matt Fullowan |
| 2011-12: Colin Ely, Matt Fullowan |
| 2012-13: |
| 2013-14: Rick Durso, Andrew Murano, Adam Schroeder |
| 2014-15: Rick Durso, Robbie King, Robert Ruiz |
| 2015-16: Rick Durso, Robbie King, Scott Stevens |
| 2016-17: Robbie King, Anthony Mancini, Antonio Pelusi, Paddy Quinlan |
| 2017-18: Anthony Mancini, Dan Martoccio, Antonio Pelusi, Paddy Quinlan |
| 2018-19: Emmett LiCastri, Anthony Mancini, Antonio Pelusi, Paddy Quinlan |
| 2019-20: Wil Gil, Brett Kulp, Emmett LiCastri, Reid Robilotto |
| 2020-21: No season |
| 2021-22: Cristiaan Dailey, Jose Diaz, Wil Gil, Cenzo Pelusi |
| 2022-23: Jack Bruce, James Conway, Noah Fox, Cenzo Pelusi |
| 2023-24: James Conway, John Crawford, Noah Fox, Pat Phillips |
| 2024-25: James Conway, Bryce Kresho, Mason Leiphart, Pat Phillips |
