All-Americans

1989: Anne Krumrine (first-team Kodak/WBCA)
1990: Anne Krumrine (first-team Kodak/WBCA)
1993: Carrie Bowen (honorable mention Kodak/WBCA)
1994: Tina Breithraupt (honorable mention DIII News & Women's Basketball Gazette)
2001: Amy Kreitz (honorable mention D3Hoops)
2002: Amy Kreitz (honorable mention WBCA)
2004: Amy Abernathy (fourth-team WBCA)
2005: Dana Johns (fifth-team WBCA)
2008: Sarah Meisenberg (honorable mention WBCA)
2012: Alexa Barbush (honorable mention WBCA)
2013: Alexa Barbush (honorable mention WBCA)

D3Hoops.com All-Region

1993: Carrie Bowen (first-team WBCA)
2002: Amy Kreitz (second-team)
2003: Amy Abernathy (second-team)
2004: Amy Abernathy (first-team)|
2005: Dana Johns (second-team)
2006: Dana Johns (second-team)
2008: Sarah Meisenberg (second-team)
2009: Sarah Meisenberg (third-team)
2012: Alexa Barbush (first-team)
2013: Alexa Barbush (first-team)

Division III National Player of the Year Finalist

1989: Anne Krumrine

NCAA All-Tournament Team

1988: Michele Fisher (regional MVP), Anne Krumrine

ECAC Southern Division Player of the Year

1990: Cathy Belser
1989: Anne Krumrine
1988: Anne Krumrine

All-ECAC

1988: Anne Krumrine (first-team), Michele Fisher (first-team), Cathy Belser (honorable mention)
1989: Anne Krumrine (first team), Michele Fisher (first team), Cathy Belser (second team), Chris Ditzler (second team)
1990: Cathy Belser, Anne Krumrine (first-team) 
1991: Carol Flinchburg (first team)
1992: Carrie Bowen (first-team)
1993: Carrie Bowen (first-team)
1994: Tina Breithaupt (second-team)
1995: Mika Lugue (second-team)
2001: Amy Kreitz (first-team)
2002: Amy Kreitz (first-team)
2004: Amy Abernathy (first-team)
2005: Dana Johns (first-team)