Year: Captain(s)
|
| 1974-75: Ali Kantor, Bridgett Russell |
| 1975-76: Ali Kantor, Bridgett Russell |
| 1976-77: Ali Kantor, Bridgett Russell |
| 1977-78: Laurie Baker, Ali Kantor, Bridget Russell |
| 1978-79: Kathleen Bonner, Wendy Stabolepszy |
| 1979-80: Peggy Truschel, Kathy Ward |
| 1980-81: Ginger Harding |
| 1981-82: Helen Cannaday, Kelly Kirker |
| 1982-83: Karen Kay, Elisa Zinberg |
| 1983-84: Barbara Curran |
| 1984-85: Gabrielle Butler |
| 1985-86: Ali Salmon, Mary Semmelhaack, Karen Steidle |
| 1986-87: Chris Ditzler, Michele Fisher |
| 1987-88: Chris Ditzler, Michele Fisher |
| 1988-89: Chris Ditzler, Michele Fisher |
| 1989-90: Cathy Belser, Anne Krumrine |
| 1990-91: Patty Borosky, Carrie Bowen |
| 1991-92: Carrie Bowen, Jen Slaybaugh |
| 1992-93: Holly Bamford, Carrie Bowen |
| 1993-94: Tina Breithaupt, Dina White |
| 1994-95: Deanna Bergondo, Aurora Gonzalez |
| 1995-96: Deanna Bergondo, Aurora Gonzalez, Mika Lugue |
| 1996-97: Aurora Gonzalez, Mika Lugue |
| 1997-98: Angel Paternostro, Kathy Raguckas |
| 1998-99: Jen Gibbon, Jocelyn Hirl |
| 1999-00: Brandy Burkett, Erika Linnander, Judy Stauber |
| 2000-01: Erika Linnander, Amanda Rader |
| 2001-02: Lauren Howanski, Amy Kreitz |
| 2002-03: Kirsten Richter, Kelly Witkowski |
| 2003-04: Ann Parker, Kelly Williams |
| 2004-05: Maura Lentz, Dana Johns |
| 2005-06: Dana Johns, Christy Strunk, Emily Weaver |
| 2006-07: Brittany Braxton, Jessica Bishop, Sarah Meisenberg |
| 2007-08: Brittany Braxton, Jessica Bishop, Sarah Meisenberg |
| 2008-09: Cara Landolfi, Mariam Marcis, Sarah Meisenberg, Amanda Miceli |
| 2009-10: Alison Menna |
| 2010-11: Alison Menna, Megan Pauley |
| 2011-12: Kristen Kudrick, Gerard Larkin |
| 2012-13: Alexa Barbush, Elizabeth Snyder, Colleen Bott |
| 2013-14: Shea Costantino, Emma Lisle |
| 2014-15: Kara Bacile, Leslie Bacile |
| 2015-16: Emily Wetz |
| 2016-17: Erica Brown, Sarah Haddon, Shannon O'Connor |
| 2017-18: Devandria Bernard, Erica Brown, Haley Pilone |
| 2018-19: Haley Pilone, Sarah Pisani |
| 2019-20: Kristin Hamill, Sarosha Parsons |
| 2020-21: Emily Moran, Kenna Williams |
| 2021-22: Maia Lockhart, Alisyn Narracci, Kenna Williams |
| 2022-23: Jaclyn Feit, Natalie Kolb, Ally Trebelev, Kennedy Wilburn |
| 2023-24: Jaclyn Feit, Hope Schreiber |
| 2024-25: Quinn Galligan, Lizzie Neville, Ally Trebelev, Kennedy Wilburn |
