| Year |
All-Conference Selections |
| 1968 |
First Team - Kim Frankford, George Dreisbach |
| 1969 |
|
| 1970 |
|
| 1971 |
First Team - Robert Hiltner, Jack Brunner, James Teagle, Jay Baumgardner |
| 1972 |
First Team - Robert Hiltner, Ed Bosch | Honorable Mention - Keith Dukes, James Teagle, Larry Shadek, Bob Olender, Jack Brunner |
| 1973 |
First Team - Clint Lynch, Ed Bosch, Bob Olender | Honorable Mention - James Teagle |
| 1974 |
First Team - Keith Dukes, Clint Lynch, Jeff Rineer |
| 1975 |
|
| 1976 |
Second Team - Larry Fine, Alex Kolobielski |
| 1977 |
|
| 1978 |
Second Team - Tom Christman, Tom Bachman, Jeff Wagner |
| 1979 |
Second Team - David Heiges |
| 1980 |
First Team - Al Taylor | Brian Fatse, David Heiges, Rick Herr, Jeff Wagner |
| 1981 |
|
| 1982 |
First Team - Dennis Dowd, Al Taylor |
| 1983 |
|
| 1984 |
Second Team - Doug Fulmer |
| 1985 |
First Team - Chris Hackman |
| 1986 |
|
| 1987 |
First Team - Dale Amos |
| 1988 |
First Team - Andy Zuch |
| 1989 |
|
| 1990 |
Second Team - Paul Olivett, Chris Rebman, Andy Zuch, Scott Focht, Jake Kolen |
| 1991 |
First Team - Jake Kolen, Chris Rebman |
| 1992 |
First Team - Jake Kolen |
| 1993 |
|
| 1994 |
First Team - Rod Mummaw | Second Team - Matt Pisano | Honorable Mention - Darren Maccanico |
| 1995 |
First Team - Bill Boyle, Eric Lanks, Tim Sheridan, Darren Maccanico | Second Team - Jesse Fluck | Honorable Mention - Brad Zerbe, Jamie McCall |
| 1996 |
First Team - Tim Sheridan | Second Team - Greg Sgambaugh, Beau Eckert |
| 1997 |
First Team - Jamie McCall, Beau Eckert |
| 1998 |
First Team - Greg Shambaugh |
| 1999 |
First Team - Greg Shambaugh | Honorable Mention - Dustin Derr, Josh Tartaglione |
| 2000 |
Second Team- Sean Calhoon |
| 2001 |
Second Team - Chris Zoeller, Don Klein |
| 2002 |
First Team - Andy Meyers, Chris Zoeller, Sal Monaco | Second Team - John Walsh, Dustin Derr | Honorable Mention - Dan Webber Gordie Eck |
| 2003 |
Second Team - Chris Smith |
| 2004 |
First Team - Dan Weber, Gary Kruger, Scott Haft | Second Team - Dan Hanecak | Honorable Mention - Rob Georgiou |
| 2005 |
First Team - Ted Serro, Corey Caruthers | Second Team - Stephen Frederick, Dan Hanecak | Honorable Mention - Jeremy Knox, Gary Kruger |
| 2006 |
First Team - Ted Serro, Gary Kruger, Eric Milavsky | Second Team - Jeremy Knox, Stephen Frederick, Rob Stern, Corey Caruthers |
| 2007 |
First Team - Dan Tischler | Second Team - Brad Andres, Pat O'Reilly, Mark Minutaglio, Rich Gallugi | Honorable Mention - Jeff Rowand, Gordon Pellegrini |
| 2008 |
First Team - Jason Anderson, Shea Moriarty | Second Team - Andrew Hanson, Matt Kalos, Patrick O'Reilly |
| 2009 |
First Team - Andrew Hanson, Mick Markel, Matt Will | Second Team - Bill Murray | Honorable Mention - Nick Rolnick, Jay Anderson |
| 2010 |
First Team - Matt Will | Second Team - Bill Murray | Honorable Mention - J.T. Triantos |
| 2011 |
First Team - J.T. Triantos, Will Benenson | Second Team - Mike Duranti, Eric Bornstein | Honorable Mention - Matt Will |
| 2012 |
Honorable Mention - J.T. Triantos |
| 2013 |
First Team - Alex Vescera, Aaron Gillette | Second Team - Brendan DeMond | Rookie of the Year - Matt Mezansky |
| 2014 |
Second Team - Rob Anderson |
| 2015 |
First Team - Dan Marano, Andrew Mascis | Second Team - Alex Guerra, David Lacobucci, Luke Seib | Honorable Mention - Christopher Vincent | Rookie of the Year - Dan Marano
|
| 2016 |
First Team - Andrew Mascis, David Lacobucci | Second Team - Mike Androconis |
| 2017 |
Second Team - Mike Androconis, David Lacobucci, Christopher Vincent, Reed Williams | Honorable Mention - Danny Blugis |
| 2018 |
First Team -Â Dan Marano | Second Team - Kengo Kawahara, Andrew Mascis | Honorable Mention - Jack Buckley |
| 2019 |
First Team -Â Jonathan Cole (CC Pitcher of the Year), Jack Buckley | Second Team - Don DiLoreto | Honorable Mention - J.J. Freeman |
| 2020 |
|
| 2021 |
First Team - J.J. Freeman (CC Player of the Year; Co-Gold Glove), Kyle Roche (CC Pitcher of the Year) | Second Team - Jakob Hoffman, Will Samuel |
| 2022 |
First Team - Spencer Berson (Gold Glove), Bobby Falese, Jakob Hoffman | Second Team - Dan Galef | Honorable Mention - AJ Desautels, Tommy Denlinger |
| 2023 |
Second Team - Tommy Denlinger, Dan Galef, Jakob Hoffman |Â Honorable Mention - Spencer Berson, Bobby Falese, Kyle Roche, Shane Rebane |
| 2024 |
First Team - Jakob Hoffman | Second Team - Kiernan Keller, Peter Mullen | Honorable Mention - Drew Butera, Bobby Falese, Michael von Zuben |
| 2025 |
First Team -Â Dan Galef | Second Team -Â Bobby Falese | Honorable Mention -Â Peter Mullen |
