Player of the Year

1960 - John Tomasko '61 (MAC) - Most Valuable Player (HB)
1964 - Seiki Murono '66 (MAC) - Most Valuable Player (QB)
1965 - Seiki Murono '66 (MAC) - Most Valuable Player (QB)
1972 - Bob Olender '73 (ECAC) (QB)
1975 - Joe Coviello '77 (MAC) - Most Valuable Player (QB)
1975 - Harry Caston '78 (MAC) - Most Valuable Kicker (K)
1976 - Joe Coviello '77 (MAC) - Most Valuable Player (QB)
1977 - John Green '78 (MAC) - Co-Most Valuable Player (QB)
1982 - Rob Shepardson '83 (MAC) - Most Valuable Player (QB)
1986 - John Travagline '87 (CC) - Player of the Year (QB)
1987 - Dale Amos '90 (CC) - Player of the Year (WR)
1988 - Jack Savage '89 (CC) - Player of the Year (DT)
1989 - Dale Amos '90 (CC) - Co-Player of the Year (WR)
1995 - Beau Eckert '97 (CC) - Offensive Player of the Year (QB)
1996 - Beau Eckert '97 (CC) - Offensive Player of the Year (QB)
2017 - Joe Granahan '19 (CC) - Defensive Player of the Year (DL)
2025 - Gary Lewis '26 (CC) - Offensive Player of the Year (WR)

Rookie of the Year

2019 - Kevonte Beard '23 (CC) (LB)

Centennial Conference Coach of the Year

2009 - John Troxell
2017 - John Troxell
2025 - Michael Phelan