Franklin & Marshall College

2007 – Kyle Turner
2008 – George Eager
2009 – John Harrison and George Eager
2010 – Jay Ridinger
2011 – John Kaschak
2012 – EJ Schneider
2013 – EJ Schneider and Frank Strumolo
2014 – Jordan Zackery
2015 – Bobby Keyes and Andrew DeStefano
2016 – Dave Shellhammer and Taalib Gerald
2017 – Tanner Erisman
2018 - K.J. Pretty
2019 - Keshon Farmer
2020 - No season
2021 - Drew Benfatti
2022 - Aaron Rascoe
2023 - Gary Lewis
2024 - Jack O'Hearen