F&M NABC Basketball All-Americans

Donnie Marsh	1977 (2nd), 1979 (2nd)
Dennis Westley	1981 (2nd)
Terry Scott	1987, 1988 (3rd)
Phil Hoeker	1989
Brad Markey	1989 (2nd)
Chris Finch	1991, 1992
Will Lasky	1991, 1992 (1st)
Charlie Detz	1994, 1995
Dave Jannetta	1994, 1995 (3rd)
Mike Mehaffey	1996
Jeremiah Henry	1996 (1st)
Alex Kraft	2000 (1st), 2001
Steve Juskin	2004
Duran Searles	2004
James McNally	2010 (2nd)
Georgio Milligan	2011 (1st), 2012 (1st)
Hayk Gyokchyan	2013 (3rd)
Brandon Federici	2018 (2nd)
Kevin Nowoswiat	2025 (1st)

F&M D3Hoops.com All-Americans

Alex Kraft	2000 (3rd)
Steve Juskin	2004 (1st)
James McNally	2009 (3rd)
Georgio Milligan	2012 (2nd)
Brandon Federici	2018 (HM)

CoSIDA Academic All-Americans

Jerome Maiatico	1997-1998	3rd Team
Jerome Maiatico	1998-1999	2nd Team
Jerome Maiatico	1999-2000	1st Team
Brandon Federici	2016-17	2nd Team
Brandon Federici	2017-18	2nd Team
Kevin Nowoswiat	2024-25	2nd Team

NCAA Postgraduate Scholarship Recipients

Jerome Maiatico

2000

Conference Players of the Year

Woody Sponaugle	1937
John DeBold	1940
Bill Wagner	1941
Bob Baron	1961
Jim Leslie	1963
Donnie Marsh	1976
Donnie Marsh	1977
Donnie Marsh	1979
Terry Scott	1987
Brad Markey	1989
Will Lasky	1991
Chris Finch	1992
Dave Jannetta	1994
Dave Jannetta	1995
Jeremiah Henry	1996
Alex Kraft	2000
Alex Kraft	2001
James McNally	2010
Georgio Milligan	2011
Georgio Milligan	2012
Hayk Gyokchyan	2013
Brandon Federici	2018
Kevin Nowoswiat	2025

Conference Scholar-Athletes of the Year

Brandon Federici	2017
Brandon Federici	2018
Kevin Nowoswiat	2025

Conference Rookie of the Year

Chris Finch	1989
Ed Plakans	1990
Brandon Federici	2015
Ignas Slyka	2017

Conference Coach of the Year

Glenn Robinson	1986
Glenn Robinson	1990
Glenn Robinson	1991
Glenn Robinson	1992
Glenn Robinson	1993
Glenn Robinson	2013
Nick Nichay	2024
Nick Nichay	2025

National Player of the Year

Georgio Milligan

2012 - DIII News

National Coach of the Year

Glenn Robinson

2009 - D3Hoops.com

Associated Press All-Pennsylvania Collegiate Team

"Gus" Lovett	1951 (1st), 1952 (2nd)
"Walt" Lentz	1951 (Honorable Mention)
"Dick" Dunn	1951 (Honorable Mention)