| Year |
All-Middle Atlantic Conference (MAC) selections |
| 1965 |
First Team - Mel Heath | Honorable Mention - Jon Frere, Richard Kaplan, Dave Sipperly |
| 1966 |
Not available in archives |
| 1967 |
Not available in archives |
| 1968 |
First Team - Geoff Becker | Second Team - Alton Stone |
| 1969 |
First Team - Alton Stone | Honorable Mention - John Morgan |
| 1970 |
First Team - Chris Franklin, Kevin Gadow | Second Team - James O' Brian | Honorable Mention - Chuck Greenslit |
| 1971 |
First Team - Chris Franklin | Second Team - Kevin Gadow, Tim Mueller | Honorable Mention - Marshall Long, John Morgan, John Martino |
| 1972 |
First Team - Chris Franklin (Co-MVP), Tim Mueller, Marshall Long | Second Team - Paul Friedman, Michael Pulwer, John Martino |
| 1973 |
First Team - Marshall Long, Rob Baker | Second Team - Paul Friedman, John Martino |
| 1974 |
First Team - John Martino (MVP), Sam Goodall, Marshall Long | Second Team - Paul Friedman, Mike Lamond |
| 1975 |
First Team - Sam Goodall, Nick DeRobertis, Richard Gray, Jon Hatch |
| 1976 |
First Team - John Conti | Second Team - Bill Levy, James Malamatis |
| 1977 |
First Team - Bill Levy, Bruce Cobb, Tom Howley, John Conti, Jon Hatch | Second Team - James Malamatis |
| 1978 |
First Team - Tom Howley, John Conti, Rubin Bard | Second Team - John Lopez-Ona |
| 1979 |
First Team - John Lopez-Ona | Second Team - David Tetenbaum, Michael Scibelli |
| 1980 |
First Team - Buzzy Vail, Joe Schaller, Steve Growney, Michael Scibelli, Larry Lachman | Second Team - Rich Dolan, Andy Grossman |
| 1981 |
First Team - Rich Dolan, Joe Schaller, Steve Growney | Second Team - Buzzy Vail, Andy Grossman, Bob Gfeller |
| 1982 |
First Team - Joe Schaller (MVP), Rich Dolan, Steve Growney, Tom Swift, Mark Howley | Second Team - Bob Gfeller |
| 1983 |
First Team - Bob Gfeller |Second Team - Niall Rosenzweig, Myles Gillespie |
| 1984 |
First Team - Peter Bidstrup, Tom Huestis, Jerry Canavan, Andy Larkin |
| 1985 |
First Team - Peter Bidstrup, Matt Carberry, Jerry Canavan | Second Team - Dan Garrett, Andy Larkin |
| 1986 |
First Team - Peter Bidstrup (MVP), Bill Canavan, Paul Varsames, Matt Carberry | Second Team - Stephen Ehrlich, Dan Garrett, Jeb Barrows |
| 1987 |
First Team - Dan Garrett (MVP), Stephen Ehrlich, Matt Carberry | Second Team - Scott Cozzens, Jeb Barrows |
| 1988 |
First Team - Jon Dale (MVP), Scott Cozzens, John Rodgers, Ken Gramas, Jeb Barrows, Phil Keating | Second Team - Brian Reilly, Eric Schlanger |
| 1989 |
First Team - John Rodgers, Alex Henry, Jon Dale, Phil Keating | Second Team - Melvin Frye, Brian Reilly, David Daily, Dave Van Metre |
| 1990 |
First Team - Jon Dale (MVP), Phil Keating, Alex Henry, Brian Reilly | Second Team - Chris Surran, Eugene Roche |
| 1991 |
First Team - Alex Hendrickson, Tim Hampson, Mike Ryan |
| 1992 |
First Team - Tim Hampson, Alex Hendrickson | Second Team - Chris Button, Mike Ryan, Sean Reilly, Mike Deyermond, John Burgess |
| 1993 |
First Team - Tim Hampson | Second Team - Chris Mergardt, Caleb Barnett |
|
|
| Year |
All-Centennial Conference (CC) Selections) |
| 1994 |
First Team - Don Gervais, Chris Mergardt, Rob Gioia, Jason Roberts | Second Team - Joe McGlone, Andrew Giobbe |
| 1995 |
First Team - Chris Mergardt, Jason Roberts, Andrew Giobbe | Second Team - Don Gervais, Andy Whitley | Honorable Mention - Jeremy Bryant |
| 1996 |
First Team - Don Gervais, Chris Mergardt, Ian Sobler, Tom Coleman, John Coleman | Second Team - Jeremy Nierman | Honorable Mention - Jon Bloom, Andy Whitley |
| 1997 |
First Team - Tom Coleman, John Greene | Second Team - Andrew Woods |
| 1998 |
First Team - Tom Coleman, John Greene | Second Team - Will Bouchard, Matt Flaherty, Marc Pascal |
| 1999 |
Second Team - Matt Flaherty, Eric Poole, Robert Michel | Honorable Mention - Brendan Bigos, Kris Weaver |
| 2000 |
Second Team - Brendan Bigos, Phil Gerster, Dave Kahn | Honorable Mention - Bryan Nolan |
| 2001 |
First Team - Greg Ivry | Second Team - Dave Taler |
| 2002 |
First Team - Chris Schelhorn | Second Team - Mike Sartorius, Jon Singer, Andrew Kuskowski | Honorable Mention - Bas Solleveld, Kris Weaver |
| 2003 |
First Team - Bryan Nolan, Jon Singer, Matt Capone | Second Team - Bas Solleveld, Dave Taler | Honorable Mention - Mike Sartorius |
| 2004 |
First Team - Steve Welsh, Matt Capone | Second Team - Bas Solleveld, Ed Schellhorn | Honorable Mention - Colin Hanley, Dave Taler |
| 2005 |
First Team - Steve Welsh, Matt Capone, Colin Hanley | Honorable Mention - Mike Orhnberger |
| 2006 |
Honorable Mention - Mike Ohrnberger |
| 2007 |
|
| 2008 |
First Team - Mark Hild | Honorable Mention - Noah Wilkinsky, Mike Orhnberger |
| 2009 |
Second Team - Justin Rayman | Honorable Mention - Noah Wilkinsky |
| 2010 |
First Team - Andrew Setian | Honorable Mention - Justin Rayman |
| 2011 |
First Team - Andrew Setian | Second Team - Fred Schweizer | Honorable Mention - Billy Kempner, Jimmy Wenk |
| 2012 |
First Team - Andrew Setian, Jimmy Wenk | Second Team - Colin McKew, Fred Schweizer |
| 2013 |
First Team - Tristan Miller | Second Team - Billy Kempner | Honorable Mention - Carlos Pelaez, Cameron Setian |
| 2014 |
First Team - Josh Kanter | Second Team - Billy Kempner, Carlos Pelaez | Honorable Mention - Chad Gamble, Jamie McCulloch, Cameron Setian |
| 2015 |
First Team - Chad Gamble | Second Team - Connor Melillo | Honorable Mention - Michael Bossidy |
| 2016 |
First Team - Sean Rogers | Honorable Mention - Michael Bossidy, Mike Wasik, Read Ziegler |
| 2017 |
First Team - Sean Rogers (Offensive POY), Kevin Mollihan (ROY), George Briggs, Nick Zenobio | Second Team - Tucker McBride, Jarrett Donaghy, Anthony Dougherty |
| 2018 |
First Team - Kevin Mollihan (Offensive POTY), Sean Rogers, Harry Rice, Jarrett Donaghy, Tommy O'Connor | Second Team - Luke Keating (ROY), George Briggs, Ellis Llewellyn |
| 2019 |
First Team - Luke Keating (Offensive POY), Kevin Mollihan, Jarrett Donaghy, Tommy O'Connor | Second Team - George Briggs, Ellis Llewellyn | Honorable Mention - A.J. Rigsby, Jack Beatty |
| 2021 |
First Team - Luke Keating (Offensive POY), Jack Beatty, Erich Della Volpe, Holden Kammerer, Eric Mueller, A.J. Rigsby, Blake Target | Second Team - Will DeMuth, Spencer Hall | Honorable Mention - Noah Isaacson |
| 2022 |
First Team - A.J. Rigsby (Offensive POY), Will DeMuth | Second Team - Kyle Craig, Spencer Hall, Noah Isaacson |
| 2023 |
First Team - Kyle Craig | Second Team - Tommy Garofalo (CC ROY), Will Mollihan |
| 2024 |
Honorable Mention - Kai Kelly |
| 2025 |
First Team - Teddy Scarborough (Defensive POY), Pierce Archer, Dillon Mannix | Honorable Mention - Jackson Barnhill, Luke Topley |
