| Year |
All-Conference Selections |
| 1949 |
First Team - George Schultz |
| 1950 |
- |
|
1951
|
First Team - Walt Lenz, Carl Yoder, Sam Yoder |
| 1952 |
First Team - Bill Lampe, Carl Yoder |
| 1953 |
|
| 1954 |
|
| 1955 |
First Team - Gerry Husted | Second Team - Jack Baker, Vern Ringler, Bob Parker, |
| 1956 |
First Team - Herb Bomberger, Gerry Husted |
| 1957 |
|
| 1958 |
|
|
1959
|
Honorable Mention - Bernie Rossini |
| 1960 |
Second Team - Dale Kessler, Bernie Rossini, Sam Nolt |
| 1961 |
Second Team - Dale Kessler, Bernie Rossini |
| 1962 |
First Team - Paul Adogli (MVP), Bill Fenstermacher |
| 1963 |
Second Team - Lance Knaugh, Paul Adogli |
| 1964 |
First Team - Paul Adogli | Second Team - Jim Bunting, George Kalule, Bob Leuffen |
| 1965 |
First Team - Bob Penney | Second Team - Jerry Rugel | Honorable Mention - Uwe Meyer |
| 1966 |
Second Team - Richard Dwyer | Honorable Mention - Uwe Meyer, Don Wright |
| 1967 |
|
| 1968 |
Honorable Mention - Carlo Mendoza |
| 1969 |
First Team - Vince Zarrilli | Honorable Mention - Paul Figley, Kayode Sokunbi |
| 1970 |
|
| 1971 |
|
| 1972 |
|
| 1973 |
First Team - Tom Gostyla |
| 1974 |
First Team - Al Sheldon |
| 1975 |
First Team - Blake Pepinsky | Second Team - Pete Anuzis |
| 1976 |
First Team - Peter Anuzis, Larry Fine, Ray Hillyard |Â Second Team - Tom Rahauser, Rory O'Connell |
| 1977 |
First Team - Tom Rahauser | Honorable Mention - George Martin, Rory O'Connell, Robert Schein |
| 1978 |
First Team - Rory O'Connell, Edward Cermack, Richard Schein, George Martin |
| 1979 |
First Team - Dennis Dowd, Edward Cermack |
| 1980 |
First Team -Â Vance Campbell, Sam Cermack, Dennis Dowd, Mike Maclntyre | Second Team - James Guthrie |
| 1981 |
First Team - Mike Maclntyre, Vance Campbell, Kevin Tyron |
| 1982 |
First Team - Todd Thayer, Kevin Tyron, Todd Silverberg | Second Team - Kurt Snyder |
| 1983 |
First Team - T.J. Devtz, Todd Thayer, Kevin Tryon |Second Team - Wooky Kwon |
| 1984 |
Honorable Mention - Kurt Snyder |
| 1985 |
First Team - Mark Micolucci | Second Team - Arman Moshyedi, Tim Stetson |
| 1986 |
First Team - Mark Micolucci | Second Team - Matt Carberry, Arman Moshyed, Victor Salama |
| 1987 |
First Team - Mark Micolucci (MVP) | Second Team - Sean McCullough |
| 1988 |
|
| 1989 |
|
| 1990 |
First Team - Anthony Vattilana | Second Team - Kevin Wiercinski |
| 1991 |
First Team - Anthony Vattilana (MVP) |
| 1992 |
First Team - Anthony Vattilana (MVP) | Second Team - Kevin Wiercinski |
| 1993 |
First Team - Kevin Wiercinski | Second Team - Bill Boyle |
| 1994 |
First Team - Jason Lennon | Second Team - Bill Boyle |
| 1995 |
First Team - Jon Lookingbill | Second Team - Derek Brogan |
| 1996 |
First Team - Jon Lookingbill |
| 1997 |
Honorable Mention - Erik McKenna |
| 1998 |
Honorable Mention - Scott Runyon |
| 1999 |
Honorable Mention - Andrew Traud, Scott Runyon, David Christiansen |
| 2000 |
First Team - Scott Runyon, Andrew Traud |Second Team - David Christiansen |
| 2001 |
First Team - Scott Runyon, David Nelson | Honorable Mention - Matt Shapiro, Chris Milano |
| 2002 |
First Team - Eric Marshall, David Nelson | Second Team - Forrest Watson, Chris Milano |
| 2003 |
|
| 2004 |
First Team - Brandon Corday | Second Team - Wallace Eisenhauer, Alex Sanchez, Dan Mills | Honorable Mention - Jose Cabelle
|
| 2005 |
First Team - Brandon Corday | Second Team - Chris Campbell, David Heller | Honorable Mention - Ben Wilson, Alex Shuptar, Ed Stelz
|
| 2006 |
First Team - Brandon Corday (MVP), Alex Shuptar | Second Team- Ed Stelz | Honorable Mention - Danny Levi, Chris Campbell
|
| 2007 |
First Team - Brandon Corday (MVP), Ryan McGonigle, Jason Keil |
| 2008 |
First Team - Eric Corsini | Second Team - Matt Krantz |
| 2009 |
First Team - Eric Corsini | Second Team - Matt Krantz, Matt Melino |
| 2010 |
First Team - Ben Beaver, Charlie Welch | Second Team - Giuseppe Bua, Zach Zamek |
| 2011 |
First Team - Ben Beaver | Second Team - Mike Irving | Honorable Mention - Preston Kilgore |
| 2012 |
First Team - Ben Beaver | Second Team - Mike Irving, Sam Lane, David Rosenfeld |
| 2013 |
First Team - David Rosenfeld (CC POTY), Ben Beaver, T.J. White | Second Team - Chris Scott |
| 2014 |
First Team - Jared Bomba, Sam Lane, David Rosenfeld, Chris Scott, Trevor Britton | Second Team - Chase TenBrook |
| 2015 |
First Team - Chase TenBrook, Trevor Britton, Devon Malfitano | Second Team - Ugo Okolie, Wyatt Fabian |Honorable Mention - Ben Wild
|
| 2016 |
First Team- Ugo Okolie, Jason Tonelli, Wyatt Fabian, David Reingold | Second Team - Ben Wild |Â Honorable Mention - Alex Bilodeau, Jeremy Levine
|
| 2017 |
First Team - Jason Tonelli, Wyatt Fabian | Second Team - Ben Draheim | Honorable Mention - Ryan Fincher, Ryan Corr
|
| 2018 |
First Team -Â Connor Whitacre | Second Team - Ryan Corr, Ryan Fincher, A.J. Kopacz, Ugo Okolie | Honorable Mention - Jim Connolly
|
| 2019 |
First Team -Â Connor Whitacre | Second Team - A.J. Kopacz, J.T. Mogan, Christopher Amoruso | Honorable Mention -Â Alex Lalovic, Shay Adamson
|
| 2020 |
Season canceled |
| 2021 |
First Team - A.J. Kopacz (OPOY), Carl Friedrich | Second Team - Shay Adamson, Sam Altman Farrell, Steven Yakita | Honorable Mention - Connor Anderko, Dallen Moore |
| 2022 |
First Team - Connor Anderko, Shay Adamson,  | Second Team - Isaac Mintz | Honorable Mention - Sam Altmann Farrell, Koa Kaliebe |
| 2023 |
First Team - Oscar Horwitz (OPOY), Connor Anderko, Koa Kaliebe | Second Team - Isaac Mintz | Honorable Mention - Nico Gonzalez, Nolan Booth |
| 2024 |
First Team - Koa Kaliebe | Second Team - Connor Anderko, Adam Green | Honorable Mention - Nolan Booth, Thomas Kaplan, Isaac Mintz |
| 2025 |
Honorable Mention - Jack Borden, Thomas Kaplan |
