National Champions
1952 (as selected by the National Intercollegiate Soccer Coaches Association)
Conference Championships
1952 - Middle Atlantic Conference
2013 - Centennial Conference
2017 - Centennial Conference
All-Americans (United Soccer Soccers/NSCAA unless otherwise noted)
Fred Weitzel - 1948 (Honorable Mention)
Walter Lenz - 1951 (Second Team), 1952 (Honorable Mention)
Carl Yoder - 1952 (First Team)
Gerald Husted - 1956 (Honorable Mention), 1957 (First tTeam)
Brandon Corday - 2006 (First Team), 2007 (First Team)
Ben Beaver - 2013 (Third Team NSCAA & D3 Soccer)
David Rosenfeld - 2013 (Third Team), 2014 (Third Team D3 Soccer)
Chase TenBrook - 2015 (First Team)
Ugo Okolie - 2016 (Third Team)
Wyatt Fabian - 2016 (Third Team NSCAAÂ & D3 Soccer)
Connor Whitacre - 2019 (First Team USC & D3 Soccer)
Shay Adamson - 2022 (Second Team)
Koa Kaliebe - 2023 (Second Team), 2024 (First Team)
Oscar Horwitz - 2023 (Third Team)
CoSIDA Academic All-Americans
Scott Runyon - 2001 - Third Team
Scott Runyon - 2002 - Third Team
Koa Kaliebe - 2023 - Second Team
Koa Kaliebe - 2024 - Second Team
Centennial Conference Coach of the Year
Dan Wagner - 2019, 2022
Conference Players of the Year
Paul Adogi - 1962
Mark Micolucci - 1987
Anthony Vattilana - 1991, 1992
Scott Runyan - 2001
Brandon Corday - 2006, 2007
David Rosenfeld - 2013
A.J. Kopacz - 2021
 Oscar Horwitz - 2023 (Offensive POY)
Conference Rookie of the Year
Janse Schermerhorn - 2014
Ugo Okolie - 2015
D3soccer.com Defender of the Year
Connor Whitacre - 2019
United Soccer Coaches All-Academic Team
2020, 2021, 2022, 2023, 2024
United Soccer Coaches Scholar-All-Americans
Koa Kaliebe - 2023 (first team)
Oscar Horwitz - 2023 (second team)
Koa Kaliebe - 2024 (first team)
