| Year: Captain(s) |
| 1927: Wallace McComb |
| 1928: Dave Chambers |
| 1929: Bill Sipple |
| 1930: Samuel Clark |
| 1931: Lester Osborn |
| 1932: Lester Osborn |
| 1933: Robert Taylor, Theodore Woodward |
| 1934: Horace Luckett |
| 1935: Horace Luckett, H. Grant Hurst |
| 1936: Fred Hocking |
| 1937: Frank Kaufman |
| 1938: Robert Chodos, Edgar Long |
| 1939: Vic Finley, Edward Plewes |
| 1940: Ernest Wehmeyer |
| 1941: William Hoyt |
| 1942: Robert Reinhard |
| 1943: No team (WWII) |
| 1944: No team (WWII) |
| 1945: No team (WWII) |
| 1946: Dick Weitzel |
| 1947: Charles Borgard |
| 1948: Dick Weitzel |
| 1949: Fred Wagner |
| 1950: Bob Bentler, Fred Wagner |
| 1951: Karl Klinges |
| 1952: Sam Yoder |
| 1953: Bob Elliot |
| 1954: Tom Headrick |
| 1955: Karl Leuffen, Bob Hitchings |
| 1956: Bob Hitchings |
| 1957: Jim Stuart |
| 1958: Herb Bomberger, Chuck Robertson |
| 1959: Brad Baker, Sam Nolt |
| 1960: Bill Hobbs, Sam Nolt |
| 1961: Burnell Rossini |
| 1962: Chuck Pfahler |
| 1963: Bruce Goodrich, Lance Knauth |
| 1964: Paul Adogli, Jim Bunting |
| 1965: Norm Werthwein, Bob Penney |
| 1966: Jon Crawford |
| 1967: Billy Cornish, Don Wright |
| 1968: Ed Gilroy, Mike Stoudt |
| 1969: Michael Hull, Alan Skulstad |
| 1970: Vince Zarrilli |
| 1971: Alan Ingraham, Henry Lane |
| 1972: Ned Abrahamson, Tom Peer |
| 1973: Tom Peer, Allen Sheldon |
| 1974: Bob Abrahamsen, Al Sheldon |
| 1975: Pete Anunzis, Ray Hillyard, John Houghton |
| 1976: Pete Anuzis, Ray Hillyard, Tom Rahauser |
| 1977: George Martin, Tom Rahauser |
| 1978: George Martin, Joe Short |
| 1979: Edward Cermack, Christopher Dean, Robert Ottersen |
| 1980: Sam Cermack, Glen Stuart, Bob Ottersen |
| 1981: Jim Carle, Mike MacIntyre |
| 1982: Scott Marwin, Richard Mason |
| 1983: Dan Bostwick, Kevin Tryon |
| 1984: Todd Silverberg, Kurt Snyder |
| 1985: Dave Siddons, Tim Stetson |
| 1986: Matthew Carberry, Mark Micolucci |
| 1987: Joe Mackin, Mark Micolucci |
| 1988: Jeff Cooper, Andy Kleff, Rich Scherer |
| 1989: Tamir Klaff, John Packard, Rich Scherer |
| 1990: John Burgess, Derek Dowsett, Tamir Klaff |
| 1991: John Burgess, Dan Feigin, Peter Feigin, Anthony Vattilana |
| 1992: Mark Fleming, Anthony Vattilana, Kevin Wiercinski |
| 1993: Bill Boyle, Brett Szczesny, Kevin Wiercinski |
| 1994: Bill Boyle, Patrick Lehman, Jason Lennon |
| 1995: Derek Brogan, Jon Lookingbill, Jordan Muller |
| 1996: Jon Lookingbill, Erik McKenna, Michael Pitone |
| 1997: Erik McKenna, Mike Pitone, Michael Rosner |
| 1998: Andrew Herson, David Taft |
| 1999: David Christiansen, Andrew Herson |
| 2000: David Christiansen, Matthew Shapiro, Andrew Traud |
| 2001: Scott Runyon |
| 2002: Todd Kehoe, Dave Nelson |
| 2003: Stephen Schneider, Gerald Stoltzfoos |
| 2004: Wallace Eisenhauer, Dan Mills, Ben Wilson |
| 2005: Dave Heller, Alex Shuptar, Ben Wilson |
| 2006: Alex Shuptar |
| 2007: Brandon Corday, Danny Levi, Jason Keil |
| 2008: Eric Corsini, Matt Melino, Danny Shuptar |
| 2009: Eric Corsini, Matt Melino, Charlie Welch |
| 2010: Charlie Welch, Adrian Heredia, Ed Stene |
| 2011: Eric Elicker, Rob Hassler, Mike Irving |
| 2012: Mike Irving, Jacob Miller, David Rosenfeld |
| 2013: David Rosenfield, Chris Scott |
| 2014: David Rosenfield, Chris Scott |
| 2015: Jeremy Levine, Devon Malfitano, Chase TenBook |
| 2016: Jeremy Levine, Ben Wild, Janse Schermerhorn |
| 2017: Wyatt Fabian, James Schermerhorn |
| 2018: Jim Connolly, Connor Whitacre |
| 2019: Will Kelley, Connor Whitacre |
| 2020: Ryan Hannum, J.T. Mogan |
| 2021: Sam Farrell, A.J. Kopacz |
| 2022: Sam Farrell |
| 2023: None selected |
| 2024: None selected |
| 2025: None selected |
