Franklin & Marshall College

Saylor was played in both the backfield and on the line, and captained the 1909 football team. That team went 10-1, outscoring opponents 201-24. Saylor coached the 1916 football and basketball squads at F&M.

Saylor became the first Franklin & Marshall College graduate to become a full-time coach at his alma mater, when he accepted the position of physical director and coach of all athletic teams in the fall of 1916.