Franklin & Marshall College

Cragin lettered in football, baseball, basketball and track at F&M. He is a National Football Hall of Fame Tri-County Member. He once dropped kicked a 53-yard field goal. He played a major role in one of F&M's most thrilled football games, kicking a 45-yard field goal with just twenty seconds remaining in the game with Gettyburg to break a 3-3 tie. The game was the largest crowd ever assembled at Williamson Field at the time.

Cragin captained the football, baseball and basketball teams. He held down first base for the diamond club.